Green Giant

Metal raised garden bed manufacturers

Tree Surround: Metal Vs. Wood

Tree Surround: Metal Vs. Wood

From the beautiful and grand old oak to the modern and sleek metal, deciding which material to use when installing a tree surround can be tricky. Metal tree surrounds offer undeniable benefits of durability, rust resistance, low maintenance, and customizable aesthetics. However, wooden tree rings can achieve a timelessly classic look that is difficult to replicate with metal. Let’s explore the positives and negatives of each type of tree surround so you can decide what’s suitable for your garden oasis!

  • Cost: Metal vs. Wood
  • Maintenance/Durability: Metal vs. Wood
  • Aesthetics: Metal vs. Wood
  • Installation Process: Metal vs. Wood
  • Impacts on Environment: Metal vs. Wood
  • Size/Weight Considerations: Metal vs. Wood
  • Suitability for Different Types of Trees: Metal Vs. Wood
  • Regulation and Permits: Metal Vs. Wood

Cost: Metal vs. Wood

When comparing the costs of metal tree surrounds versus wood tree surrounds, there are a few factors to consider.

The cost of a metal tree surround will undoubtedly be higher than a wooden one due to the materials used. However, many homeowners prefer the look of metal because it is more modern and weather-resistant. Additionally, metal tree surrounds require less maintenance and upkeep since they are not as prone to rotting or warping as wood can be in certain climates.

Wooden tree guards are an excellent option for those looking for a more traditional aesthetic, as they blend into landscaping better than metal. They require more maintenance, though, as they need regular sealing and treatment with products such as preservatives or paint. Wooden tree guards also tend to cost less upfront but may cost more in the long run due to preservation costs.

Both metal and wood tree guards can be good options depending on budget, desired aesthetics, and climate conditions. Researching each type thoroughly to determine which is right for you is vital when deciding.

Recommended Articles: ↓

Tree surrounds: Aluzinc vs. Galvanized Metal

Maintenance/Durability: Metal vs. Wood

[Metal Tree Surrounds]
Advantages: Metal tree surrounds are robust, durable, and resistant to weathering and rust, which makes them an excellent choice for outdoor settings. They are also relatively easy to clean with just soap and water.
Disadvantages: Metal tree surrounds can be pretty expensive compared to other materials like wood. They can also become very hot in direct sunlight and are prone to denting or warping if not correctly cared for.

[Wooden Tree Surrounds]
Advantages: Wooden tree surrounds offer a classic look while being cost-effective compared to metal options. Wood is also easier to customize with patterns, textures, or paint than metal species.
Disadvantages: Wooden tree surrounds require regular maintenance and protection from the elements to last long-term. They might need sanding or resealing annually, depending on their exposure level.

Get the complete solution: ↓

Tree Surround

Aesthetics: Metal vs. Wood

When deciding on the perfect tree surround for your garden, there are two main choices – metal or wooden. Each material has unique aesthetic qualities, which will help you determine which is best suited for your project.

Metal tree surrounds often come in modern designs and sleek lines, providing a minimalist and contemporary look to any outdoor space. They can also be easily customized with decorative pieces such as sculptures or awnings. On the other hand, wooden tree surrounds bring an inviting warmth and natural beauty to any setting. The rustic charm of wood offers an earthy feel that is hard to find elsewhere.

Installation Process: Metal vs. Wood

Metal and wood are two of the most popular materials when installing a tree surround. Although both materials have their benefits when it comes to installation, there are some critical differences between the two that should be considered when making a decision.

Advantages of Wooden Tree Surrounds
When it comes to installation, wooden tree surrounds are often much easier for DIY-ers, as they usually require fewer tools and are more user-friendly. In addition, wooden tree rings can generally be purchased in standard sizes so they can easily fit into existing spaces without requiring additional cutting or modification. Additionally, wood tree rings create an aesthetic around the tree while maintaining year-round beauty.

Advantages of Metal Tree Surrounds
Metal tree surrounds also have their advantages when it comes to installation. They generally require less maintenance than wooden trees since they need not be stained or treated with any sealant over time. However, metal tree rings need additional tools, such as saws and drills, for installation since metal tends to be more complicated than wood. Additionally, metal tree surrounds may not provide an aesthetic look as desirable as their wooden counterparts. They can begin looking rusty or scuffed over time if not treated properly on occasion.

Choosing between a metal or wood tree surround will depend mainly on individual needs and preferences. Those who want an easy installation process with minimal tools might opt for a wooden surround, whereas those who prefer a low-maintenance solution may choose metal. Careful consideration should be given to what type best suits particular needs before committing to any material in particular.

Impacts on Environment: Metal vs. Wood

Metal and wooden tree surround can significantly impact the environment, positively and negatively.

When it comes to metal tree surrounds, one of the significant benefits is that they are highly durable. This means they didn’t need to be replaced regularly, saving energy and resources. They also require less maintenance over time, which minimizes the associated costs. However, metal tree surrounds can be vulnerable to rust and corrosion if not kept in optimal conditions.

Wooden tree surrounds are more environmentally friendly as wood is typically sourced from renewable sources. They are also aesthetically pleasing, as wood grain can add warmth and character to any outdoor space. However, wooden tree surrounds may require regular staining or painting over time to prevent rot or weather damage. They also may not last as long as their metal counterparts.

Overall, metal and wooden tree surrounds can have a robust environmental impact if managed correctly. Those looking for an environmentally friendly option should consider using sustainable materials such as recycled plastic or composite lumber for their surroundings instead of traditional metal or wood.

Size/Weight Considerations: Metal vs. Wood

Metal and wooden materials are the two most popular options when choosing a tree surround for your landscape. But before making a final decision, it is essential to consider the different size and weight considerations of metal and wooden tree surrounds.

Metal tree surrounds tend to be sturdier and more durable than wooden ones because they’re made from solid materials such as steel. However, metal also tends to be heavier than wood, so if you don’t have an adequate foundation or plan to relocate your tree surround in the future, this could be problematic.

Wooden tree surrounds boast a unique aesthetic that is hard to replicate with metal. They may not be as sturdy as metal but are usually lighter; this makes them easier to install and remove when needed. The only downside of timber is that it needs more care when exposed to extreme weather conditions to prevent rotting or cracking.

In conclusion, weighing all the size/weight considerations before opting for a metal or wooden tree surround for your garden is essential. Both can have advantages depending on what you need from your tree surround, so research and choose the one that best fits your requirements!

Suitability for Different Types of Trees: Metal Vs. Wood

Metal and wood tree surrounds are suitable for different types of trees, depending on the kind of trees, size, and climate. For example, if you have a species of tree sensitive to colder temperatures, metal might be a better choice due to its ability to maintain heat. On the other hand, wooden tree surrounds might be better in warmer climates because they can provide insulation against extreme temperatures. Ultimately, it’s up to the owner of the trees to decide which option will work best for them.

Regulation and Permits: Metal Vs. Wood

Concerning tree surrounds, metal and wood have become popular options for homeowners. While both materials effectively promote tree health and stability, they differ regarding regulation and permits.

Metal tree surrounds often require permits from local planning commissions before any work may commence. This is because metal requires specialized installation equipment that may be seen as intrusive in residential neighborhoods. Additionally, metal tree surrounds are usually considered more permanent than wooden ones, which can require permits or not, depending on height and size restrictions.

Wooden tree surrounds generally do not require permitting as they tend to be seen as less intrusive than metal assemblies. However, regional building laws might require enclosure sizes to be within specific dimensions to preserve the safety of people walking nearby. Furthermore, wood is susceptible to rotting over time due to harsh weather conditions, whereas metal tends to remain intact longer with minimal maintenance required.

Overall, there are pros and cons between metal and wooden tree surrounds regarding regulations and permits. Homeowners should know these differences to find the best option for their landscape requirements and local laws.


In conclusion, metal and wood have pros and cons for tree surroundings. Metal is light, durable, and rot-resistant but can be expensive. Wood is more affordable than metal but will require more maintenance over time. Ultimately, the right choice will depend on your personal preference, budget, and needs. With proper care, either material could make a great tree surround for any outdoor space.


Gardening blogger

Meet Even, a distinguished collaborator at Green Giant. With over a decade of hands-on experience in the niche of raised garden bed cultivation, she brings an unparalleled depth of knowledge to our team. Her expertise, honed over years of experimental gardening, provides an insightful perspective on the practicalities and nuances of this unique form of horticulture.

You May Like
You can always contact us!
Scroll to Top

Send an inquiry now

Please fill out the form below to send us your request.

I will respond within 24 hours.

Contact Form Demo